Rawlings-NAIA Football Player of the Year
From Varsity Pride
The Rawlings-NAIA Football Player of the Year Award is a college football award given each year to the most outstanding player in NAIA football.
| 1997 | Bo Hurley | Findlay | quarterback |
| 1998 | Jack Williams | Azusa Pacific | running back |
| 1999 | Eddie Eviston | Georgetown (KY) | quarterback |
| 2000 | Eddie Eviston (2) | Georgetown (KY) | quarterback |
| 2001 | Eddie Eviston (3) | Georgetown (KY) | quarterback |
| 2002 | Nick Kortan | Sioux Falls | running back |
| 2003 | Tyler Emmert | Carroll (MT) | quarterback |
| 2004 | Cory Jacquay | Saint Francis (IN) | running back |
| 2005 | Tyler Emmert (2) | Carroll (MT) | quarterback |
| 2006 | Brian Kurtz | Saint Francis (IN) | linebacker |
| 2007 | Chad Cavender | Sioux Falls | quarterback |
| 2008 | Owen Koeppen | Carroll (MT) | linebacker |
| 2009 | Lorenzo Brown | Sioux Falls | quarterback |
| 2010 | Jon Ryan | Sioux Falls | wide reciever |
| 2011 | Chance Demarais | Carroll (MT) | running back |
| 2012 | Jimmy Coy | Saint Xavier | quarterback |
| 2013 | Kyle Schuck | Morningside | wide receiver |
| 2014 | Austin Dodge | Southern Oregon | quarterback |
